Artificial Intelligence in Mental Health: How It Improves Care

توضیحات

“What is artificial intelligence?” This has been a common question since AI emerged as a field in the 1950s. In recent years, alongside questions about what AI actually is, inquiries about its various applications have rapidly become widespread. It is clear that this phenomenon can be applied in virtually every aspect of human life. One of the most challenging and perhaps most unexpected uses is artificial intelligence in mental health to improve human well-being. Therefore, if you are interested in the topic of artificial intelligence, its functions, and its use in mental health, stay with Porfiro until the end to learn more about this subject in a fully scientific yet simple language.

Definition of artificial intelligence

A computer keyboard covered with greaseproof paper and open only on the letters A and I next to each other for the article Artificial Intelligence in Mental Health: How It Improves Care

There are many proposed definitions of artificial intelligence, but whatever the definition, they all usually revolve around machines behaving like humans or developing computer programs. The father of artificial intelligence, John McCarthy, defined the process as: “making a machine behave in ways that would be called intelligent if a human were to behave that way.”

McCarthy indicated the goal of AI was to make machines behave as if they are intelligent. Over the last few decades, the area of AI has moved from working on toy problems, such as chess, to learning new skills, and discovering the limits of the toy problems. After sixty years of research and development, AI has found its way into industries and public consciousness.

Presently, in the 21st Century, AI has affected all aspects of our lives to such a degree that we are living in the “Age of Artificial Intelligence.” AI differs from computer science, as its definition has evolved and become even looser through the variety of concepts of intelligence. AI is thought of as a computer system that, in many aspects, resembles the human mind.

In fact, artificial intelligence is an umbrella term that encompasses a variety of approaches and techniques for building computational systems that can perform cognitive processes and tasks. These processes and tasks can include learning, reasoning, and generalization.

Read More:

Artificial intelligence (AI) and its application in nutrition

Background, history and evolution of artificial intelligence

Artificial Intelligence started in the 1950s when efforts commenced on machines with a limited ability to make decisions like humans and reason. The greatest milestones were made decades later, the most significant being Unimate (1961), which was the first industrial robotic arm in the world, and Eliza, a chatbot that could communicate with humans (1964), which laid the groundwork for the development of future robotics and AI.

The contemporary concept of artificial intelligence came into existence in the mid-20th century when scientist Alan Turing envisioned the theoretical basis of AI with the Turing Test and envisioning for universal computing machines. In 1956, John McCarthy coined the term ‘artificial intelligence’ as ‘the science and engineering of making intelligent machines,’ thereby establishing AI as an academic discipline.

AI experienced a series of epoch-making milestones. 1956 Dartmouth Workshop, popularly referred to as birth of AI, saw scientists get together with the common aim of making machines that would “think”. During the subsequent decades strategies developed towards making systems to operate on symbols controlled by logic.

In the 1980s, we witnessed increasing numbers of expert systems striving to mimic human expert-like behavior within limited domains by applying rule-based systems. The rule-based systems could not capture or handle the uncertainty and richness of the real world and gave rise to the start of the era of “AI winter” that was an era when hope and funds dropped precipitously for the study of AI, carried on into the early 1990s.

But then, in the latter half of the 20th century we witnessed increased interest in AI and this is because there were several reasons such as improvements in machine learning that enabled neural networks to be able to model complex structures. With growing demand for machine learning and with better algorithms, neural networks regained ground attention during the 1990s.

The 21st century has witnessed gigantic steps in AI, primarily due to the fact that there is more computer power and more data sets. The actually real breakthroughs which were achieved through deep learning methods in numerous domains like natural language processing and picture recognition changed our knowledge of human vision or language entirely.

In addition, it also must be mentioned here that some actually real “AI” breakthroughs were achieved during this time also, such as IBM’s Watson – a computer software program that dominated the quiz TV show contest Jeopardy! in 2011, was the unmistakable demonstration of such early breakthroughs. Following these breakthroughs, the rapid acceleration of AI advancement in the medical industry (and many, many others) quickly ensued.

Introduction to the components of AI and artificial intelligence in mental health

In the field of mental health care, various elements of artificial intelligence collaborate in innovative ways. Below are different AI components used in this area:

  • Machine learning: Used to analyze patient data and predict mental health conditions.
  • Supervised learning: Helps in more accurate identification of mental disorders.
  • Unsupervised learning: Applied for discovering behavioral patterns and detecting hidden problems.
  • Natural language processing: Employed in analyzing texts and speech to identify emotional states and patient needs.
  • Reinforcement learning: Used to design dynamic interventions and optimize treatment methods.
  • Computer vision: Utilized in analyzing images and detecting structural anomalies related to mental health.

These technologies generally offer promising pathways to enhance positive mental health outcomes and have transformed our approach to supporting psychological well-being. You will learn more about this topic below.

An overview of the applications of AI in mental health care

Awareness: How can artificial intelligence be used to raise awareness about mental health disorders?

With the use of sophisticated technologies like natural language processing, sentiment analysis, and data mining, AI projects have demonstrated a staggering potential in spreading correct information, stigmatization, and promoting mental health conversations. The integration of AI and mental awareness is a new paradigm that has the potential to change the manner society takes to understanding and discussing mental disorders.

The capacity of AI to analyze and process large data sets, along with its capacity to interact with human beings, offers good potential for the development of effective awareness campaigns. An example of the application of AI in mental health awareness is social media data analysis and organization.

Twitter and Instagram have user data that can be utilized to monitor public opinion concerning mental health issues. Artificial intelligence-based sentiment analysis software can recognize emotions expressed in postings, helping researchers and mental health groups monitor shifts in public discourse and find most salient subjects that need targeted awareness campaigns.

Sentiment analysis can assist an individual in measuring shared attitudes, stereotype views, and shifting attitudes surrounding mental health. AI technologies have provided an interactive medium to deliver the most precise mental health information and educational content.

Most of these AI chatbots encourage users to discuss their feelings in an affirmative way, as well as provide suggestions, coping strategies, and referrals to qualified people and other support systems. Chatbots are reducing the barriers to receiving knowledge and access to support relating to mental illness, and ultimately start to shift attitudes toward seeking support when necessary.

Psychological education is an essential part of awareness programs about mental health through dissemination of important information and coping skills to the masses. AI-driven educational websites facilitate this process by employing data mining technology to personalize content as per multifarious user needs. Personalization elevates user participation and allows education content to be significant and real based on individuals’ lives, thus leading to improved mental health issue understanding.

Support: How can artificial intelligence support individuals with mental disorders?

Mental illness is an international threat and needs innovative solutions to assist people in their pursuit of health. The intersection of mental illness and artificial intelligence has provided the birthplace of innovative solutions that harmonize with old ways. AI, with its sophisticated algorithms and capacity to process vast data sets, has the capacity to significantly support individuals afflicted by mental illness in the following ways:

  1. Early detection: AI is able to detect early warning signs of mental illnesses like depression and anxiety through the patterns of behavior. Early detection provides intervention in a timely manner before the disease progresses.
  2. Sentiment and behavioral analysis: AI technologies are capable of web-based behavior, writing, and speech analysis to determine symptoms of anxiety and depression. This allows therapists to detect patient needs on time and offer interventions in a timely manner.
  3. 24/7 assistance: AI-based chatbots and virtual assistants can provide assistance at any moment, which is particularly useful for people who require immediate assistance during crisis time.
  4. Personalized treatment: AI can process humongous amounts of patient information and determine treatments most suitable for a particular person. This enables therapists to come up with more specified and customized treatment strategies.
  5. Cost reduction: Having AI utilized in counseling and psychological therapy can be cost-saving as demand for human counselors or psychologists per session is less.

These applications show the great potential of AI in changing mental health care. With the integration of latest technologies, new techniques can be formed to treat people with mental disorders such that services are more accessible and the quality improves.

Mental health professionals can embrace positively the AI-based client engagement methods to effectively guide the recovery process of individuals with mental diseases. For example, AI technology can be naturally integrated into mobile applications that provide timely medication reminders, side effects monitoring, drug reaction monitoring, enhanced compliance, and cooperation between individuals and healthcare providers. AI-based mood-tracking apps also track mood swings and provide information on potential triggers so that individuals can see patterns and make informed self-care choices.

The concept of the digital footprint or digital phenotype of an individual is based on the implementation of digital data to quantify and monitor the mental condition of a human being. AI can scan what individuals share on social media, their medical background, and other platforms. AI can identify sudden changes in behavior that relate to mental diseases.

For instance, if someone wears a smartwatch to monitor physical activity on a daily basis but suddenly goes from being highly active to being largely sedentary, AI technology would read this as a likely indication of depression. This would fall into the normal pattern of lower energy and desire to engage in physical activity that is typically evident in mornings with depression.

In addition, AI has the ability to cement relationships among people facing identical challenges by facilitating virtual support groups and networks where the individual can share experiences and advice. AI interventions that track an individual’s improvement from the long term and provide feedback on the efforts one makes can also sustain motivation for recovery.

Intervention: In what ways can artificial intelligence contribute to the intervention of mental illness and as a therapeutic intervention for mental illness?

Artificial intelligence (AI) of all types—most commonly machine learning—has enormous potential for predicting, diagnosing, and implementing therapeutic interventions related to care for mental health problems. It can also assist mental health professionals reshape the way we define psychiatric disorders; AI can reveal when psychiatric disorders exist at their most premature and earliest stages and it can have implications for successful intervention.

Increasingly, AI is enabling personalization of treatment for each individual(s) based on their own unique characteristics. In action on prediction and prevention, AI can identify those at risk of developing specific types of mental disorders based on their unique profiles, known genetic predispositions, and environmental circumstances, allowing for intervention before a disorder develops or worsens.

AI has advanced to sophistication levels in decision support systems (DSS) that can systematically screen for specific mental disorders and clinically diagnose an individual. AI algorithms are capable of analyzing diverse sources of data, including electronic health records, diagnostic tests, and behavior patterns to identify early signs of mental health issues, which allows for timely intervention providing a better prognosis.

Regarding treatment, numerous research studies have established that chatbots using NLP can identify mental health problems through question-based procedures like those utilized by mental health professionals. Chatbots, for example, can query individuals on various domains like mood, stress, energy, and sleep behavior. The responses are reviewed, enabling the chatbot to recommend various therapeutic interventions.

These recommendations may include behavior adjustment in the form of exercise such as walking, meditation, relaxation, or referring the individual to seek professional medical intervention. Moreover, where immediate protection is needed, the chatbot may immediately notify medical professionals.

As therapeutic interventions have increased, AI can augment current interventions by allowing cognitive-behavioral treatment and training through digital media. These tools support understanding, provide ongoing guidance, and track progress in the long term. AI-based mental health apps deliver convenient and accessible care to individuals, especially those with impaired access to traditional clinical care, with on-demand assistance and reduced barrier to seeking assistance.

Although, AI-based neurofeedback and brain-computer interfaces offer innovative mechanisms for controlling brain activity and emotional states. Brain-computer interfaces offer individuals instantaneous feedback regarding mental states, enabling them to learn self-regulation skills. Finally, AI is tasked with interpreting patient information, generating insight and suggestions for clinicians to help inform treatment choices, thereby maximizing clinical outcomes.

In addition to the vast number of AI applications enhancing awareness, assistive systems, and interventions across mental health, there is a need to look at the specific benefits such AI-fueled applications bring.

Benefits of AI in mental health

Graphic illustration of a large AI in the shape of a human head with a child standing in front of it and interacting with it for the article AI in Mental Health: How it Improves Care

Positive impact on cognitive aspects

Presently, cognitive assessments are recognized to be useful tools employed when diagnosing and treating mental disease. These assessments are composed of various tests and activities that help quantify cognitive functions such as language, memory, judgment, and attention. Nonetheless, one of the biggest challenges in this field is the subjectivity and inaccuracy of these assessments. Therefore, several medical professionals seek to automate them.

In this respect, artificial intelligence (AI) turned out to be the ultimate solution. Advanced AI techniques will increase the accuracy and objectivity of mental tests. The technology will facilitate better detection of cognitive deficits in their early stages, providing the opportunity for earlier intervention.

One of the key advantages of AI in this regard is the sheer volume of data that it will ultimately be able to process. Machine learning algorithms, such as support vector machines and neural networks will be able to analyze data and produce accurate results. This will speed up, and enhance the accuracy of diagnosing mental disorders.

Also, computerizing the evaluation process allows experts to dedicate more time to dealing with their patients and reduce the burden of work. Because experts have some limits to their performance, AI can support raising the quality of the services provided.

Later on, with the development of AI technologies, we can expect that diagnosis and treatment of mental health disorders will enhance. Not only do they enhance the accuracy of diagnosis but also, they can improve the lives of people who suffer from mental health disorders.

Intellectual and developmental disorders

Cognitive (or intellectual) and developmental (or functional) disabilities consist of cerebral palsy, Down syndrome, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Also falling under the cognitive (or functional) disability umbrella are autism spectrum disorders and fragile X syndrome). The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends screen 3-year-olds for developmental and autism spectrum disorders during usual primary care visits.

Cognitive and developmental disabilities are generally diagnosed in children before age 18. Diagnosis of cognitive (and developmental) disabilities is critical for timely intervention to improve life-style outcomes, and artificial intelligence is proposed to be an innovative tool; currently, AI could be employed to screen subjects under consideration for a diagnosis.

For example, AI can be used to evaluate neuroimaging data as well as that derived from analyses based off of deep neural networks (DNN) to detect cognitive disorders. Additionally, AI could be employed to analyze eye movements to classify an individual as an autism spectrum disorder patient or not.

Maternal autoimmune biomarkers and blood tests could also be pertinent to screening for a cognitive disability. AI uses, like other technology, can improve the accuracy of diagnostics to improve developmental intervention and improve quality of life of the child and social impacts for affected families.

Neurodegenerative disorders

Some diseases, like Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s, can be difficult to diagnose since the symptoms may not present until there are many damaged brain cells. Sometimes early diagnosis or detection is near impossible. But luckily for us, artificial intelligence seems to have remedied that. Researchers can apply new technologies to examine brain MRI images and determine early indications of those diseases.

For example, the AI model “Support Vector Machine” can identify with high accuracy whether an individual has Alzheimer’s disease or not, and distinguishing those with Alzheimer’s with those without is still possible. There are also three-dimensional neural networks, which are incredibly accurate. Overall, AI has made identifying diseases in the brain easier, thus allowing more hope for individuals related to treatment and management options.

Seizure

Epileptic seizures result from sudden, abnormal electrical activity in the brain. The challenge of diagnosing seizures arises from various patterns of seizures. Prior research has demonstrated the effectiveness of analyzing electroencephalogram (EEG) recordings by machine learning algorithms to effectively detect seizures.

Positive impact on emotional/sensual aspects

The combining of artificial intelligence and affective computing has driven what we now term “Emotional AI.” Within these disciplines we have developed methods to detect emotional states and humans and respond accordingly. Though we are still in the early stages of Emotional AI, they are expanding into various areas of our lives, ranging from personal devices, to work to educational settings.

A significant aspect of emotional AI is emotion sensing, and it comes from affective computing that originated in the 1990’s. Fortunately, in this case “emotion” can be technology with fairly simple and limited AI to recognize emotional states and the factors affecting them, emotionally, cognitively, and even physiologically.

Essentially, emotion sensing uses input and analyzes it from different sources: words, images, facial expressions, gaze direction, body movements, voice, and also physiological signals related to humans and their emotions like heart rates, and body temperature.

The input can consist of facial images or expressions, voice samples, or biofeedback data, which will help humans become aware of their feelings; and have the ability to interact with their technology and media content better. This type of technology also builds emotional self-awareness and understanding.

While we typically employ machine learning techniques to perform these tasks, the overall intention of Emotional AI is exciting our interactions with technology and enhance our emotional experiences.

Artificial Intelligence and Emotional Well-being

This technology has the potential to exceed human limits, permitting detection of more subtle emotional signals and signals of emotion with more precision using wearables and smartphone applications; moreover, with artificial intelligence (AI), emotion regulation, and personalized interventions are possible.

In real time, using data on people’s emotions, AI-based computational systems can give immediate strategies, interactive practices, and simulations to manage emotional states. For example, AI-based apps can provide users with practices for doing relaxation exercises, deep breathing, or mindfulness activities action to reduce stress, and help develop their self-regulation.

AI’s role with emotional health is significantly broader than detecting and regulating emotions. AI systems can be used to develop emotional intelligence as an important form of balance in maintaining emotional states. AI can provide trajectories of users’ emotional signals over time in order to further understand their feelings and the contextual triggers of these feelings, thus equipping an individual with skills to manage feelings better and to respond constructively to life events.

On another level, AI-based interfaces and applications are also able to modify their responses based on user emotional cues and can provide forms of empathetic and supportive interactions. These intelligent emotional interfaces demonstrate the act of human communication, and this type of communication can help users to create the emotional experience they expect while supporting their emotional needs.

Emotional Regulation Disorder

Emotional regulation disorder refers to difficulties individuals have with regulating and expressing their emotions effectively. This can lead to intense emotional reactions, mood lability, and maladaptive emotional functioning, increasing one’s vulnerability to depression, anxiety, and drug abuse disorders. Artificial intelligence would be a huge asset in this treatment. Some are:

  1. Music-based emotion regulation applications: There have been applications created using music to train the emotion regulation skills in individuals with mental disorders both clinically and socially. They range from eating disorders, anxiety disorders, drug use, and schizophrenia.
  2. Virtual reality and therapeutic games: Therapeutic virtual reality worlds and AI-based therapeutic games provide engaging environments for the practice of emotion regulation. Interactive platforms provide safe environments in which one can build up their emotion regulation over time.
  3. Biofeedback and neurofeedback systems: AI-based biofeedback and neurofeedback systems allow people to become more aware of their physiological response as a function of emotional regulation disorder and gain more control over them. Biofeedback and neurofeedback systems give users immediate feedback on heart rate, brain waves, and other physiological signals and assist in the capability to learn modulation of emotional responses.
  4. Instant empathetic assistance: Instant empathetic assistance can be offered by virtual therapists or AI-powered chatbots for individuals with emotional regulation difficulties.

Mood Disorders

Mood disorders are mental health issues that affect an individual’s emotional state, often involving extreme and abnormal shifts in mood. They include major depression and bipolar disorder. Artificial intelligence can help in this regard in various ways:

  • Utilization of AI techniques: Many AI techniques can be utilized to assess mood disorders and risk of suicide. Mobile and wearable technologies, combining subjective reports and physiological/behavioral signals, provide real-time and proximal analyses of features indicative of conditions like depression and bipolar disorder.
  • Social media posts: AI can offer more than the above, for example, it can monitor social media posts and text messages for linguistic features or language use and conduct sentiment analysis. Ultimately, this could provide predictions of changes in mood or the risk of a return of major depressive episodes.
  • Social rhythm metrics: Another important example is that the social rhythm metric (SRM) has been clinically validated in the assessment of stability and rhythm in patients diagnosed with bipolar disorder. The SRM can be automatically computed using sensor data emitted through mobile cellular phones – which can provide a personalized mechanism to assess and self-monitor the risk of severe mood episodes.

Autism Spectrum Disorder

Autism Spectrum Disorder refers to conditions affecting interaction and communication in individuals. Artificial intelligence is well-suited to help in this moment in the following ways:

  • AI tools: Specific platforms based on artificial intelligence will assist in the early diagnosis of ASD by analyzing facial movements, eye trackers and hand movements during video interactions to recognize the signs of autism.
  • Smart tablets: Smart tablets can represent a new clinical assessment model, and proved effective in identifying ASD and interventions on young children.
  • Custom games and sensors: These aspects can form custom games that include many psychometric assessments, a novel design and use of sensors to assess e.g. social intelligence, or emotional reaction on the android device through front facing cameras, games with educational toys and sensors could be used to deepen the effectiveness.
  • Diagnostic Model: It has been established through research that AI models correctly diagnose autism 100% of the time, most notably utilizing retinal images. This progress can mitigate fears about limited access to appointment-based specialized assessments and promote objective screening resources for autism.

Schizophrenia

Schizophrenia is a severe mental illness and is diagnosed by symptoms that include hallucinations, disorganized speech, and disturbances to thoughts and emotions. Artificial intelligence has also been helpful in treating the disorder:

  • Automated speech analysis: Automated speech analysis offers the ability to assess speech patterns and vocal tone to detect the subtle but clinically relevant emotional changes that would suggest beginning symptoms of the disorder before they are clinically apparent. This technology can enhance clinicians’ abilities to decode symptoms and track the development of the disorder.
  • Natural Language Processing (NLP) based tools: Natural Language Processing (NLP) based artificial intelligent (AI) tools allow speakers to track speech patterns to demonstrate or predict the relapse of the symptoms in relationship to the speech and emotional content. These methods, augmented by AI, allow practitioners to recognize the emotional shifts and engage in the appropriate intervention.
  • AI interventions for youth: The use of AI interventions could contribute to emotional health in children and adolescents. The application of interactive or engaging AI-based platforms also makes available appropriate formats for emotion regulation and stress management. AI-based platforms could include immersive virtual reality games or even simply engage as a virtual companion.
  • Monitoring of online activities: Finally, AI can be utilized as a monitor of online activities or social media use to trace or spot signs of cyberbullying or anxiety or depression in a young person. The ability to recognize signs early, with the assistance of AI methods is both useful and can help mitigate emotional issues and develop health emotional coping skills and potentially prevent depressive issues from escalating.

Disadvantages of using AI applications in mental health

A humanoid robot for the article Artificial Intelligence in Mental Health: How it Improves Care

There are many positive applications of artificial intelligence (AI) within the realm of mental health care, including more accurate diagnosis, personalized treatment, and enhanced access to mental health treatment. However, there are genuine ethics and privacy issues that must be addressed before effective use of safe, efficient, and ethical AI can be achieved. Some of the major concerns are:

  • Privacy and Data Security: Most AI systems of any sort that there are in mental health treatment are generally using some type of potentially sensitive personal information regarding patients, including their history medically, health care history, and occasionally information about their emotional status over a period. It should be necessary to ensure that such information is protected and maintains privacy rights and security from invasion and data loss.
  • Informed Consent: Patients with mental illness ought to be informed about the way in which the data will be used, and the effect that this information may have on the patient with the sole purpose of being provided with therapy through the use of AI. Informed consent is especially needed when dealing with mental health data because the information may be personal and confidential.
  • Transparency: Mental health care AI models must not only be transparent but also explainable. Health care providers and patients must be told how AI systems make their decisions so that there can be accountability as well as trust.
  • Bias and Justice: The AI programs are prone to inheriting bias in the training data and, as a result, can perpetuate inequities in diagnosis and treatment advice. Every effort must be made to identify and overcome such bias in order to treat everyone equally and justly.
  • Human Monitoring: While AI may be able to aid mental health treatment, human intelligence cannot be replaced outright. Human decision-making needs to be used to validate AI-based recommendations to avoid future mistakes and to ensure the ethical soundness of caregivers.
  • Accountability and Legal Responsibility: Where the treatment of mental health is decided by AI systems, accountability and legal responsibility come to the forefront. In case liability for adverse effects resulting from AI recommendations has to be determined, it can be problematic and requires careful thought.
  • Patient-Provider Relationships: AI impacts patient-provider relationships. Empathy, trust, and the human touch in mental health interactions continue to be essential, even when using AI systems.
  • Unintended Consequences: AI technologies can inadvertently intensify overdiagnosis or medicalization of typical emotional experiences. The AI algorithms need to be controlled and modified tightly to prevent such unintended consequences.
  • Regulations and Protocols: Legal and ethical principles need to be properly established to control the creation, deployment, and use of AI in mental health treatment. The regulations need to safeguard patients’ rights, privacy, and welfare.

All these challenges must be taken up in a serious way to enable the application of developing technologies like AI in mental health to be fruitful and ethical.

Digital medicine is currently experiencing an increasingly deep integration with artificial intelligence (AI). In terms of psychiatric research and care, this is extremely promising and could transform our understanding, diagnosis, and treatment of various mental disorders. However, there are a number of limitations we need to be aware of before continuing to embrace this opportunity—most notably, the issue of generalizability, the need to keep research alive and ongoing, and certainly the rapidity of the technology limitation itself.

In conclusion, we need to ensure the deep integration of AI into health care in general to ensure we are maximizing the benefits of this phenomenon. AI and health care should together mutually assist in the area of positive mental health.

Integrative actions should take place among clinicians, scientists, patients, and regulators together to ensure we are making the transition to integrate AI into mental health care responsibly—we cannot be passive in waiting for using AI to develop. AI in health care can be a promising process-to-process-to-practice continuum, and we need to engage ourselves if we are to inform and ‘shape’ AI in clinical care that will lead to improved patient services.

10233

دیدگاه ها

دیدگاهتان را بنویسید

نشانی ایمیل شما منتشر نخواهد شد. بخش‌های موردنیاز علامت‌گذاری شده‌اند *